Skip to content

Knowledge that lights the world

The Ottoman Millet System: Six Centuries of Different Faiths Living Side by Side

Muslims, Greek Orthodox Christians, Armenians and Jews lived side by side in Ottoman cities for centuries. The religious communities known as “millets” had their own schools, courts and leaders. How this order worked, its limits and how it unravelled in the modern age.

The Ottoman Millet System: Six Centuries of Different Faiths Living Side by Side

This article is part 18 of the series “How Did the Turks Shape World History?”.

At its greatest extent the Ottoman state ruled millions of people speaking dozens of languages and holding different faiths. One of the most important arrangements that held this diversity together for centuries was the structure, which historians call the “millet system”, organising society by religious community. In Ottoman Turkish, “millet” meant a religious community rather than a “nation” in the modern sense.

Roots: the idea of protection (dhimma)

Under Islamic law, non-Muslim subjects known as “dhimmis” paid a tax called the jizya and in return enjoyed a status in which their lives, property and freedom of worship were guaranteed by the state. This principle had been applied in Islamic states since the time of the Prophet. The Ottomans inherited it and adapted it to a vast, multi-faith empire. The fact that people’s religion, churches and local customs in conquered regions were largely left untouched was one of the factors behind the durability of Ottoman rule.

Patriarchs and chief rabbis

Shortly after the conquest of Constantinople, in 1454, Sultan Mehmed II appointed the Orthodox scholar Gennadios Scholarios as Greek Orthodox patriarch and granted him a warrant (berat). The event became a symbol of the Ottomans’ relationship with non-Muslim communities. According to tradition, the Armenian Patriarchate of Istanbul was founded in 1461. Jewish communities also had their own rabbis and communal institutions; the office of chief rabbi gained official status in the 19th century.

These religious leaders managed their community’s family law — marriage, divorce and inheritance — ran their schools, hospitals and foundations, and mediated between their communities and the state. Non-Muslims could also turn to the Islamic courts if they wished; Ottoman archives show that Christians and Jews brought many cases among themselves before the kadı.

1492: a new home for the Sephardic Jews

In 1492 many of the Jews expelled from Spain settled in Ottoman lands with the permission of Sultan Bayezid II. Salonica soon became one of the most populous Jewish cities in the world. Sephardic Jews contributed greatly to the Ottoman state in printing, medicine and trade; the first printing press in Ottoman lands was set up in Istanbul in the early 1490s by Jewish printers to print Hebrew books. Ladino (Judaeo-Spanish) was for centuries one of the languages of Ottoman cities.

Living together in daily life

In cities such as Istanbul, Salonica, Izmir, Sarajevo and Aleppo, mosque, church and synagogue often stood in the same neighbourhood or very close together. Masters of different faiths worked side by side in craft guilds. Mimar Sinan’s team included Greek and Armenian builders, and Armenian and Greek composers wrote important works of Ottoman music. Works in Karamanlidika (Turkish written in Greek letters) and in Armeno-Turkish (Turkish in Armenian letters) show that Turkish was also a shared language of these communities.

An honest look: order, not equality

The millet order was not a system of equality in the modern sense. Non-Muslims paid the jizya, generally did not serve in the army, and were at times subject to restrictions concerning dress, riding horses or building new places of worship. The devshirme — the levy of boys from Christian families — was also a harsh practice viewed in different ways today. Yet when one considers that in the same period religious difference led to expulsions and wars of religion in many parts of Europe, the Ottoman order offered a remarkably stable model of coexistence.

Historians also stress that it is hard to speak of a uniform, official institution called the “millet system” in the classical period: arrangements varied by region and era, and the system took its institutional form largely in the 19th century.

Reform and dissolution

In the 19th century the Ottoman state embarked on reforms defining all its subjects as equal citizens. The Tanzimat Edict of 1839 and the Reform Edict of 1856 proclaimed security of life, property and honour and equality regardless of religion, and with the Constitution of 1876 deputies of different faiths sat in the first Ottoman parliament. The aim was to unite all communities under a shared “Ottoman” identity.

In the same century, however, nationalist movements spreading from the Balkans, interventions by the great powers and successive wars shook this structure. In the empire’s final decades, wars, rebellions, mass migrations, deportations and population exchanges broke apart the centuries-old multicultural fabric amid great suffering affecting all communities.

What remains today

The Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Armenian Patriarchate in Istanbul, historic synagogues and churches; the mosque, cathedral and synagogue within a few hundred metres of each other in Sarajevo; and the Ottoman-era buildings of Thessaloniki are traces of this long shared past still visible today. Ottoman cuisine, music and language live on as the common heritage of many peoples of the region.

Frequently asked questions

Could non-Muslims hold state office in the Ottoman Empire?

In the classical period high military and administrative posts were largely open to Muslims, but non-Muslims played important roles as interpreters, physicians, financiers and merchants. From the 19th century non-Muslims were also appointed to the highest offices, including minister and ambassador.

Why did the word “millet” change meaning?

In Arabic the word means “religion, community of faith”. With the spread of nationalist ideas in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, it came to be used in Turkish in the sense of “nation”.

Sources and further reading

  1. Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı İslâm Ansiklopedisi, “Millet Sistemi”, “Zimmî”, “Cizye”.
  2. Benjamin Braude and Bernard Lewis (eds.), Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Empire (1982).
  3. İlber Ortaylı, İmparatorluğun En Uzun Yüzyılı (The Empire’s Longest Century).
  4. Karen Barkey, Empire of Difference: The Ottomans in Comparative Perspective (2008).
Share
Follow YulaHubGet the day's most important stories first.
RSS

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *