Zhizhi was one of the chanyus who rose to prominence during the Xiongnu civil war. He defeated his brother Huhanye and took the northern part of the Xiongnu lands, but his position weakened when Huhanye won the support of Han China.
Moving west
Zhizhi refused to submit to Han China and moved west, fighting the Wusun and other peoples along the way. At the invitation of the ruler of Kangju, in today’s Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, and in alliance with him, he settled on the Talas River and had a fortress built there.
The Western Hunnic State
Around the Talas, Zhizhi built a powerful centre that collected tribute from neighbouring peoples. Turkish historiography calls it the “Western Hunnic State”, distinct from the Eastern Xiongnu. But his relations with Kangju gradually soured, and his harsh treatment of Han envoys provoked Chinese anger.
Death
In 36 BC the Han officials in the Western Regions, Chen Tang and Gan Yanshou, marched on Zhizhi’s fortress with a large army raised without the emperor’s explicit permission. The fortress was besieged and taken, and Zhizhi was wounded and killed. The independence of the Western Xiongnu ended with this event.
Background of the Xiongnu civil war
To understand Zhizhi’s story, we first have to look at the situation inside the Xiongnu homeland in the middle of the 1st century BC. The Xiongnu state had swung between war and peace with Han China for centuries. Famines on the northern steppe, livestock losses and the long pressure of Han armies, however, weakened the Xiongnu. Tribal leaders disagreed about who should inherit the throne, and several men proclaimed themselves shanyu at the same time. Chinese sources describe this turmoil with expressions such as the period of the “five shanyu”.
Two brothers stood out in this rivalry: Huhanye and Zhizhi. Huhanye turned south and sought an alliance with Han China, while Zhizhi wanted to build an independent Xiongnu state in the north. The split between them was more than a throne dispute; it was a clash of two foreign policies. One sought security in exchange for tribute and gifts, the other defended the steppe tradition without ever accepting Han overlordship. The Hanshu chapter on the Xiongnu records this internal struggle in detail.
The fortress at Talas and the relationship with Kangju
Zhizhi’s road to the west was not easy. According to Chinese sources, he clashed with the Wusun and neighbouring communities along the way and in some places defeated them. In the end he settled around the Talas River at the invitation of the ruler of Kangju. Kangju was a steppe state in the Syr Darya basin, in the area of modern Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, and it may have regarded an alliance with the powerful Xiongnu shanyu from the east as a counterweight against the Wusun.
Zhizhi had a fortress-city built on the banks of the Talas. Chinese sources describe the settlement as a strong walled centre built with a large labour force, from which tribute was collected from the surrounding peoples. Yet relations with Kangju worsened over time. The sources report that Zhizhi treated his ally harshly and mistreated Han envoys. This harshness upset local balances and strengthened the view at the Han court that the problem of an independent shanyu in the west had to be solved.
The Han expedition and the siege
The highest Han official in the west was the Protector-General of the Western Regions, Gan Yanshou, and his deputy was Chen Tang. According to Chinese sources, Chen Tang drew up a decree without waiting for the emperor’s approval and gathered Han soldiers and allied units in the region; Gan Yanshou initially opposed the decision but finally joined the expedition. By Han law this was a serious overstepping of authority, and the pair later faced the danger of prosecution. Because the campaign succeeded, however, they were not punished.
The combined army advanced to the Talas region by different routes. Zhizhi’s fortress was besieged; the defenders resisted for a while, but the walls were breached. In this battle in 36 BC Zhizhi was killed and his head was sent to the Han capital. The Han court celebrated the victory as a major event, because the idea that anyone who defied Han would be punished however far away they were reinforced Han influence along the Silk Road.
Historical significance and debates
Zhizhi’s death meant the end of the independent Xiongnu structures built against China. While Huhanye’s line remained at peace with the Han, the western Xiongnu structure created by Zhizhi disappeared. In Turkish historiography this event is regarded as an early example of the division of the Xiongnu and of westward migration. Even so, how institutionalised Zhizhi’s state was remains debated because of the scarcity of sources; almost all of our information rests on Chinese sources, which tell events from the viewpoint of the Han court.
Popular accounts sometimes claim that Roman soldiers were present at the siege of Talas. This idea is a hypothesis put forward in the 20th century by Homer Dubs, based on a description of a defensive formation “arranged like fish scales” in some Chinese texts. In academic circles, however, this view is not accepted as proven; it remains a hypothesis because it is not supported by archaeological or genetic data. It is healthier for readers to rest on the core events based on sources: the civil war, the westward move and the siege of 36 BC.
What to keep in mind when reading the sources
Almost all texts describing Zhizhi come from the historiography of Han China. The authors of the Hanshu record events from the viewpoint of the Han court, that is, within a framework that treats an independent shanyu on the steppe as a “rebel”. For this reason, numerical details about Zhizhi’s fortress, such as troop numbers and casualty figures, may contain exaggeration or propaganda. Historians evaluate such figures not as firm data but as clues showing the meaning the Chinese court attached to events.
On the other hand, the Xiongnu side’s own voice has not reached us directly; there is no strong evidence that the Xiongnu had a written historical tradition. Our knowledge about Zhizhi is therefore both incomplete and one-sided. Archaeological work, especially in the Talas Valley and the steppe settlements around it, may offer a more balanced picture of the material culture of this period. As such studies continue, the real nature of the structure Zhizhi built may be better understood. Readers should avoid firm conclusions and keep the limits of the sources in mind.
Sources and further reading
- Ban Gu, Hanshu, chapters 70 and 94.
- Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı İslâm Ansiklopedisi, “Hunlar”.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Xiongnu”.
- Ban Gu – Hanshu, chapters 70 and 94
- Türkiye Diyanet Foundation Encyclopaedia of Islam – “Hunlar” entry
- Encyclopaedia Britannica – Xiongnu
- Ban Gu – Hanshu, chapters 70 and 94
- Türkiye Diyanet Foundation Encyclopaedia of Islam – “Hunlar” entry
- Encyclopaedia Britannica – Xiongnu
People also ask
Who was Zhizhi Chanyu? Zhizhi (Çi-çi in Turkish) was the Xiongnu chanyu who refused to accept his brother Huhanye’s submission to Han China and moved west to preserve his independence.
When did Zhizhi Chanyu reign? Reign: 56 – 36 BC.
When did Zhizhi Chanyu die? Died: 36 BC, siege by a Han army.
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *