Skip to content

Knowledge that lights the world

How Are the Oscars Decided? The Academy, Nominations and the Voting System

Who gives cinema’s most prestigious award, how are nominees chosen, and why is “Best Picture” voted on with a different system? How the Academy Awards work, from the first ceremony in 1929 to today.

How Are the Oscars Decided? The Academy, Nominations and the Voting System

The Oscars, officially the Academy Awards, are the best-known and most prestigious awards in cinema. They are presented by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, founded in Hollywood in 1927. The first ceremony, on 16 May 1929 in Los Angeles, was a simple dinner lasting about 15 minutes; today it is a show watched by millions around the world.

Who votes?

The Oscars are decided not by a jury but by the Academy’s members. More than 10,000 members — actors, directors, writers, cinematographers, editors and other film professionals — are divided into branches by profession. Membership is by invitation; in recent years the Academy has sought to strengthen diversity by increasing members from different countries and backgrounds.

Nominations

To be eligible, a film must have had a theatrical run in selected US cities within a set period. At the nomination stage each branch votes in its own category: actors nominate actors, directors nominate directors, cinematographers nominate cinematography. Best Picture nominees are chosen by all members. In the International Feature Film category, each country may submit only one film.

Choosing the winners

In the final vote all members may vote in every category, and in most categories the nominee with the most votes wins. Best Picture is different: since 2009, with more than a handful of nominees, members rank the films in order of preference. If no film receives more than half of the first preferences, the film with the fewest votes is eliminated and its ballots move to their next choice; this continues until one film has a majority. The film with the broadest support thus wins. Since the 2022 ceremony the category has had a fixed ten nominees each year.

The statuette and records

The gold-plated statuette is about 34 centimetres tall and weighs 3.9 kilograms; the origin of the nickname “Oscar” is uncertain. The films with the most Oscars, 11 each, are Ben-Hur, Titanic and The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King. The individual with the most Oscars is Walt Disney.

How can a film become eligible for an Oscar?

Not every film can enter the Oscar race. Under the Academy's rules, to count as a feature a film must run longer than 40 minutes and be shown in cinemas in the United States within a given calendar year. For the general categories, a film must play in a commercial cinema in one of the Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco Bay Area, Chicago, Atlanta or Dallas–Fort Worth areas for at least seven consecutive days, with several screenings a day.

In recent years the Academy has tightened its rules: for Best Picture contenders it introduced a wider theatrical release and inclusion standards covering representation on screen, behind the camera or in industry training. Because the rules are republished every year, the details can change.

How does the International Feature Film category work?

Until 2019, this category was called “Best Foreign Language Film”. Here films are submitted by countries, not by studios: each country may send the Academy a single film chosen by its own selection committee. Most of the film's dialogue must be in a language other than English.

The films sent by countries are first watched by a committee of Academy members, who draw up a shortlist; then the five nominees are chosen. The award goes to the submitting country rather than the director, which is why the category is seen as a kind of national showcase for world cinema.

Frequently asked questions

Who counts the votes?

Votes are counted by an independent accounting firm, and the winners’ names are kept secret until the ceremony. Representatives of the firm bring the envelopes to the stage.

Sources and further reading

  1. Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, “Rules” and “History” pages.
  2. Oscars.org, official awards database.
  3. Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences – Academy Awards Rules (oscars.org)
  4. Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences – Best Picture Inclusion Standards
Share
Follow YulaHubGet the day's most important stories first.
RSS

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *