We often see that even people who excel at maths, are experts in their work and are extremely intelligent make money decisions they regret: shares sold at a loss in a panic, investments made at the last minute because “everyone is buying”, credit card purchases that later seem pointless… The cause is usually not a lack of knowledge but the way the human mind works when faced with money.
Behavioural finance, which combines economics and psychology, studies the mental shortcuts and biases that affect people’s financial decisions. In this article we explain the most common traps and the practical defences you can use against them.
What is behavioural finance?
For a long time classical economic theories assumed that people always make rational decisions. Psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, with the prospect theory they published in 1979, showed that people systematically make “irrational” decisions under uncertainty. Kahneman was awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2002 for this work. The economist Richard Thaler received the same prize in 2017 for his contributions to behavioural economics.
Seven mental traps that affect our money decisions
- Loss aversion: Research shows that people feel a loss about twice as strongly as a gain of the same size. That is why we tend to hold on to a losing investment “in case it comes back” and to sell a winning one too early.
- Herd behaviour: Seeing everyone invest in something creates a “fear of missing out”. Most bubbles inflate through this behaviour, and those who join last lose the most.
- Overconfidence: After a few successful trades we believe we can beat the market. Retail investors who trade frequently are known to often earn lower returns because of commissions and poor timing.
- Anchoring: The first number that sticks in our mind affects later decisions. If you saw a share at its peak, you may think that price is its “real value”; the old price of a product that looks discounted has the same effect.
- Mental accounting: We treat money differently depending on its source. A bonus or tax refund is easily spent like “found money”, while the same amount from a salary would be used more carefully. Yet money is money.
- Choosing instant gratification: We prefer a small reward today to a bigger reward in the future. Constantly putting off retirement savings is a typical result of this tendency.
- Confirmation bias: After deciding on an investment, we start to see only news and comments that support our decision and ignore information that points to risks.
Emotions and market cycles
As markets rise, optimism and greed grow; as they fall, fear and panic grow. Driven by these emotions, many investors buy high and sell low, doing exactly the opposite of what they intended. Research shows that because of the timing of their moves in and out of funds, the returns investors actually earn often fall short of the funds’ own returns.
That is why, for long-term investors, the most important skill is not so much picking the right share as sticking to the plan in hard times. Recognising your emotions is the first step to managing them.
The role of psychology in spending
The psychology of money is not only about investing. Paying by credit card reduces the “pain” of spending compared with paying cash and can lead to spending more. Subscriptions build up unnoticed because the amounts are small. Social media can also lead us to compare ourselves with other people’s lifestyles and to spend unnecessarily.
Practical defences against mental traps
- Automate: Set up automatic transfers to savings and investment accounts as soon as your salary arrives. A system that does not require you to decide is more reliable than one that depends on willpower.
- Make a written plan: Write down why, for how long and in what you will invest. When markets swing, this plan will guide you.
- Set a waiting rule: Wait at least 24 – 48 hours before unplanned large purchases and sudden investment decisions.
- Check your account less often: Watching long-term investments every day triggers loss aversion.
- Diversify: Not relying on a single asset limits the damage if you turn out to be wrong.
- Seek the opposing view: Before an investment decision, also read sources explaining why that investment might be bad.
Money and happiness
Research shows that up to a certain income level money markedly increases life satisfaction, after which the effect diminishes. One of money’s most valuable functions is that it gives people time and freedom of choice. That is why making a financial plan based on your own goals rather than on other people is better for both your wallet and your mental health.
This article is for general information only and is not investment advice; you can consult a professional about your personal financial decisions, and this content is not a substitute for professional advice.
Frequently asked questions
What is loss aversion?
It is the tendency of people to feel a loss more strongly than a gain of the same size. This tendency can lead to holding losing investments longer than necessary.
Who founded behavioural finance?
The work of psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky laid the foundation of the field, and Richard Thaler made important contributions to behavioural economics.
How can I avoid emotional investment decisions?
Making a written plan, automating investments, checking your account less often and applying a waiting rule to sudden decisions are methods that work.
Why does a credit card make you spend more?
Because no money leaves your hand when paying by card, the “pain” of spending is felt less, which can make spending easier.
Sources and further reading
- Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk”, Econometrica, 1979
- Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow, 2011
- Morgan Housel, The Psychology of Money, 2020
- Nobel Foundation, Richard H. Thaler, Prize in Economic Sciences 2017 (nobelprize.org)
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *