A blockchain has no single bank or server keeping the records; computers around the world each hold a copy of the ledger. The rules that let these computers agree which transactions are valid, without allowing the same money to be spent twice, are called a “consensus mechanism”. The two most common are proof of work and proof of stake.
Proof of work
In proof of work, used by bitcoin, “miners” try to solve a mathematical puzzle that requires a huge number of attempts in order to add a new block. The first to solve it adds the block and receives the reward. Anyone wanting to alter past records would have to control more than half of the network’s total computing power, which makes attacks very expensive. The price of this security is high energy use: University of Cambridge estimates put the bitcoin network’s annual electricity consumption on a par with that of some mid-sized countries.
Proof of stake
In proof of stake, blocks are created by “validators” instead of miners. To become a validator you must lock up (stake) a certain amount of the network’s cryptocurrency as collateral. The order in which blocks are proposed is set by a selection that takes the amount staked into account. A validator who breaks the rules has part of its stake cut (slashing). Ethereum switched from proof of work to proof of stake with “The Merge” in September 2022; the Ethereum Foundation said the switch cut the network’s energy use by about 99.95%.
Comparison
- Energy: Proof of work needs intensive energy; proof of stake is far more efficient.
- Security model: In proof of work the cost of attack is hardware and energy; in proof of stake it is acquiring a large amount of crypto and risking losing it.
- Centralisation concerns: In proof of work, mining can concentrate in large firms with cheap energy; in proof of stake, large holders and big staking services can gain weight.
- Track record: Proof of work has run bitcoin without interruption since 2009; proof of stake is newer but spreading.
What is staking?
Many exchanges and platforms let users earn rewards by staking their assets. These rewards are not guaranteed, and there are risks such as being unable to access assets during the lock-up period, price falls, platform risk and slashing. In some countries staking services are also regulated.
Ethereum's big switch: The Merge
The biggest example of a move from proof of work to proof of stake is Ethereum. On 15 September 2022, with an upgrade called "The Merge", the Ethereum main network was joined to the Beacon Chain, which runs on proof of stake instead of mining. The network did not stop during the transition; users' balances and applications stayed as they were.
According to the Ethereum Foundation's estimate, the network's energy consumption fell by about 99.95 percent with the transition. However, lowering transaction fees or speeding up the network was not the aim of this upgrade; those issues were left to later scaling work.
The 51 percent attack and security
In both methods, the security of the network depends on how expensive it is for a malicious actor to take control of the system:
- In proof of work: The attacker needs to control more than half of the network's total computing power (hash power); this means enormous hardware and electricity costs.
- In proof of stake: The attacker needs to own a large share of the locked (staked) assets.
- Penalty mechanism: In proof of stake, part of the staked assets of validators who break the rules is cut through "slashing".
Small, little-used networks are more exposed to such attacks because the cost of an attack is low. This article is for general information only; it is not investment advice.
This article is for general information and is not investment advice. Crypto assets are very high risk and you can lose your entire investment. Consult a licensed professional and check the regulations in your country before deciding.
Frequently asked questions
Could bitcoin switch to proof of stake?
Technically possible, but because most of the bitcoin community sees proof of work as the basis of the network’s security and neutrality, such a change is not expected in the near future.
Sources and further reading
- Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, “Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index”.
- Ethereum Foundation, ethereum.org “Proof-of-stake” and “The Merge”.
- Satoshi Nakamoto, “Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System” (2008).
- ethereum.org – The Merge
- ethereum.org – Ethereum energy consumption
- Nakamoto, S. (2008). Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *