Skip to content

Knowledge that lights the world

Comparing Health Systems: How Do the US and Major European Countries Work Differently?

The US spends more on health than any other country; so why are outcomes not better? The Beveridge and Bismarck models, the US mixed system, spending, coverage, waiting times, out-of-pocket costs and practical information for people living abroad.

Comparing Health Systems: How Do the US and Major European Countries Work Differently?

How people access healthcare, how much they pay and who is insured differ greatly from country to country. The United States spends more on health than any other country in the world, both per person and relative to the size of its economy, yet it lags behind many European countries on some basic health indicators such as life expectancy. This is increasing interest in how different health systems work.

In this article we compare, from a neutral perspective, the health systems of the US and major European countries in terms of their basic models, financing, coverage and patient experience.

The basic models of health systems

  • The Beveridge model: Healthcare is financed by general taxation and largely provided by the state. The UK’s NHS (National Health Service), founded in 1948, is the best-known example of this model. Spain and the Nordic countries use similar approaches.
  • The Bismarck model: Employees and employers pay contributions into compulsory health insurance funds. Rooted in 1880s Germany, this model is applied in different forms today in countries such as Germany, France, the Netherlands and Belgium.
  • Mixed system: In the US, private insurance, employer insurance and public programmes exist side by side.

How does the US system work?

In the US, a large part of the working-age population gets health insurance through their employer. There is the federal Medicare programme for people aged 65 and over, and the Medicaid programme, run jointly with the states, for people on low incomes. The 2010 Affordable Care Act significantly reduced the number of uninsured people by regulating individual insurance markets and providing subsidies. Even so, part of the population is still uninsured, and those who are insured can face high co-payments and deductibles.

Spending and outcomes

The US spends about a sixth of its GDP on health, well above the EU average. The reasons for the high spending include high prices for medicines and services, administrative costs and intensive use of advanced technology. Yet life expectancy at birth in the US lags behind most Western European countries. It is stressed that this gap is linked not only to the health system but also to factors such as diet, obesity, road accidents and income inequality.

Strengths and weaknesses of European systems

  • Strengths: Near-universal coverage, generally low out-of-pocket costs and a low risk of bankruptcy due to health problems.
  • Weaknesses: In some countries, long waiting times for specialist appointments and planned surgery, resource shortages and staff gaps.
  • Shared pressures: An ageing population, rising chronic disease and expensive new treatments are also straining European systems financially.

Strengths and weaknesses of the US system

  • Strengths: Wide access to advanced medical technology, short waiting times and world leadership in medical research and drug development.
  • Weaknesses: High costs, the risk of losing coverage when changing jobs because insurance is tied to employment, and complex billing.

Differences in patient experience

The differences between systems are also reflected in the patient’s everyday experience. In many European countries patients first see a family doctor and usually reach a specialist through their referral. This “gatekeeper” approach helps control costs but can slow access to specialists. In the US, depending on the insurance plan, it may be possible to reach specialists more directly; but which doctors and hospitals are in the insurer’s network greatly changes the amount to be paid.

Drug prices also make a big difference. In most European countries the state or insurance bodies set drug prices by negotiating with manufacturers; in the US, drug prices are generally much higher.

The system in Türkiye

In Türkiye, the Health Transformation Programme of the 2000s merged different social security institutions under the Social Security Institution, and coverage was greatly expanded through General Health Insurance. The system carries elements of the contribution-based Bismarck model; private hospitals and supplementary health insurance are also widely used.

For people living abroad and travellers

  • EU citizens temporarily staying in another EU country can access necessary treatment with the European Health Insurance Card.
  • It is important for people moving to another country to find out in advance how to register with the local system and what the waiting times are.
  • For travellers to the US, comprehensive travel health insurance is recommended, given that medical costs can be very high.

This article is for general information only; it is not insurance or medical advice. You are advised to consult an expert adviser for your insurance decisions; this content is not a substitute for professional advice.

Frequently asked questions

Why is healthcare so expensive in the US?

High prices for medicines and services, administrative costs and intensive use of advanced technology are cited among the main reasons.

What is the NHS?

It is the UK’s national health system, founded in 1948, financed by general taxation and largely free at the point of use.

What is the Bismarck model?

It is a system in which employees and employers pay contributions into compulsory health insurance funds. It is applied in different forms in countries such as Germany, France and the Netherlands.

Why can waiting times be long in Europe?

Resource and staff constraints, rising demand and an ageing population lengthen waiting times for specialist appointments and planned surgery in some countries.

Sources and further reading

  1. OECD, “Health at a Glance 2023: OECD Indicators” (oecd.org)
  2. OECD and European Commission, “Health at a Glance: Europe 2024” (oecd.org)
  3. The Commonwealth Fund, “Mirror, Mirror 2024: A Portrait of the Failing U.S. Health System” (commonwealthfund.org)
  4. WHO Regional Office for Europe, “Health Systems in Transition” country reports (who.int/europe)
Share
Follow YulaHubGet the day's most important stories first.
RSS

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *