"Paying rent is throwing money away" is something people often say. Yet buying a home is also a big financial decision with costs of its own, and the right choice depends on where you live, house prices, interest rates, your income and your life plans. This article summarises the main questions to consider when deciding, wherever you are.
The real cost of buying
The cost of buying is not just the price of the home and the mortgage repayments:
- Down payment: In most cases a significant share of the price must be paid up front.
- Mortgage interest: On long-term mortgages, the total interest paid can approach the price of the home itself.
- Transaction costs: Property transfer taxes, estate agent fees, valuation, legal and notary costs.
- Ongoing costs: Property tax, insurance, service charges, maintenance and repairs. Setting aside a small percentage of the home's value each year for maintenance is common advice.
The hidden advantages of renting
- Flexibility: You can move easily if you change jobs or relocate to another city.
- Lower upfront costs: No large down payment is needed; your savings can be put to work elsewhere.
- Maintenance: Major repairs are usually the landlord's responsibility.
The advantages of buying
- Building wealth: With each repayment your share of the home grows, and over the long term the home may rise in value.
- Housing security: You are free from the risk of rent increases and being forced to move.
- Freedom: You can furnish and renovate the home as you wish.
Questions to ask before deciding
- How long will you stay? It takes time to recover transaction costs; if you are likely to move within a few years, renting usually makes more sense.
- Do you have an emergency fund? After the down payment and costs, you should still have savings to cover several months of expenses.
- Can you afford the repayments? Could you keep paying if interest rates change or your income falls?
- What is the price-to-rent ratio? If a home costs many times its annual rent, renting can be relatively more attractive; if the ratio is low, buying may come out ahead.
- Opportunity cost: What could the money for the down payment have earned over time if invested another way?
The price-to-rent ratio: a quick comparison measure
A simple measure often used to roughly compare renting and buying is the “price-to-rent ratio”. A home's sale price is divided by the annual rent for the same home. For example, if a home worth 3 million lira rents for 15,000 lira a month, the annual rent is 180,000 lira and the ratio is about 17. The higher this ratio, the relatively cheaper it becomes to rent rather than buy in order to live in the same home; the lower it is, the more attractive buying appears.
This measure is only a starting point. On its own it cannot decide for you without taking into account mortgage interest, service charges, taxes, insurance, maintenance costs, moving costs and how many years you plan to live in the home.
Opportunity cost: what could the deposit have done elsewhere?
- The alternative to the deposit: If you stayed renting, the deposit put into a home could have been placed in another savings vehicle; this forgone income is also part of the cost.
- Liquidity: A home cannot be turned into cash easily or quickly; in an emergency, a sale can take months and be costly.
- Flexibility: For people likely to change jobs or cities, the freedom of movement that renting provides has a monetary value.
The right answer differs from person to person. Running the numbers with your own figures before deciding, and consulting an independent expert if necessary, is the soundest approach. This section is for general information only and is not investment advice.
Frequently asked questions
Is rent really money thrown away?
No. Rent is the price of the housing you use. Homeowners also have "unrecoverable" costs such as interest, taxes, maintenance and opportunity cost; the fair comparison is against those costs.
Do homes always rise in value?
Homes have risen in value over the long term in many places, but prices can also fall and vary widely from area to area. Treating a home purely as a guaranteed investment is risky.
This article is for general information and is not financial advice. Consult a professional before making major financial decisions.
Sources and further reading
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) – Buying a House: tools and resources for homebuyers
- MoneyHelper (UK) – Renting or buying: which is right for you?
Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *